THE INVISIBLE LAWYER

Loading...

11/21/2017

Need Both Gender-justice and Minority Rights, Not Either-Or! by Albeena Shakil - Lawyers Collective

THE INVISIBLE LAWYER SPECIAL ISSUE TRIPLE TALAQ 1STSEPTEMBER, 2017

Need Both Gender-justice and Minority Rights, Not Either-Or! by Albeena Shakil By Albeena Shakil There are many forms of divorce practiced by Muslims. Talaq, that is divorce at the instance of a husband, is of three types — talaq-e-ahsan and talaq-e-hasan that involve proceedings spread over three months with possibilities of reconciliation, and talaq-e-biddat, which is irrevocable instant triple talaq. Then there is the Khula, which is divorce at the instance of a wife, and Mubarah, which is divorce by mutual consent.

http://www.lawyerscollective.org/the-invisible-lawyer/need-gender-justice-minority-rights-not-either

1/3

11/21/2017

Need Both Gender-justice and Minority Rights, Not Either-Or! by Albeena Shakil - Lawyers Collective

Poster made by south Asian women by FAO NGO South Asia Programme At the very outset of the Shayara Bano vs. Union of India, the five-faith Supreme Court bench deemed it fit to limit its consideration to talaq-e-biddat or instant triple talaq. In the judgement, three of the five judges of the bench, in their wisdom, did not deem it fit to suggest the legislative route for remedy. One found the practice of triple talaq “un-Islamic,” while two found it arbitrary and “unconstitutional”. Finally, a divided bench set aside the practice of talaq-e-biddat or instant triple talaq by a majority of 3:2. Legitimate concerns have been expressed at the absence of reasoning based on genderdiscrimination in any of the rulings of the judgment. But questions of jurisprudence aside, the verdict is welcome. It does away with an appalling practice that has been causing incremental pain to Muslim women, especially in the era of instant messaging, cell phones, Facebook, etc. Due credit must be accorded for this to all the Muslim women petitioners, Muslim women’s organizations and other women’s rights activists and organizations.

http://www.lawyerscollective.org/the-invisible-lawyer/need-gender-justice-minority-rights-not-either

2/3

11/21/2017

Need Both Gender-justice and Minority Rights, Not Either-Or! by Albeena Shakil - Lawyers Collective

However, despite setbacks in the court, the ruling dispensation and Prime Minister Modi have been claiming credit for the verdict, mainly in the absence of robust positions on triple talaq by most opposition parties.

An excerpt from the 395-page judgement is revealing, wherein the bench recounts “an interesting incident” with “relevance to the outcome of the present matter.” The said incident concerns a difference between the Attorney General’s oral and written submissions before the court arguing that all three types of talaqs be declared unconstitutional. The judgement notes: “One of us (U.U. Lalit, J.), enquired from the learned Attorney General, that if all the three procedures referred to above, as were available to Muslim men to divorce their wives, were set aside as unconstitutional, Muslim men would be rendered remediless in matters of divorce? The learned Attorney General answered the querry [sic] in the affirmative. But assured the Court, that the Parliament would enact a legislation within no time, laying down grounds on which Muslim men could divorce their wives.” (pp. 124-25) In forwarding this argument, the AG went much beyond the prayer of the Muslim women petitioners and also beyond his own written submission. Given the government’s dismal track record with respect to the minorities, this casual readiness to suspend a few legal rights, purportedly temporarily, raises ominous doubts about the reliability of the present government in reforming Muslim personal laws in the legislative domain. It is no wonder that many heaved a sigh of relief when the Supreme Court did not recommend the legislative option in the present case. However, this juncture brings the current predicament into particularly sharp focus. Last year, Rajya Sabha MP, Husain Dalwai, moved a private member’s Bill in Parliament – Dissolution of Muslim Marriage Bill, 2016– that is expected for discussion during the Winter Session. Since Muslim marriage is conceived as a contract between two parties, the Bill seeks to lay down gender-just terms, conditions and obligations for dissolution of the contract that are not spelt out by the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937. No longer content with a piecemeal approach towards advancing women’s rights, many Muslim women’s organizations also seek codified family laws. For instance, contrary to general apprehensions about the minority ruling of the Supreme Court judgment on Triple Talaq, Zakia Soman, founder member of the Bharatiya Muslim Mahila Andolan, took heart from the very same ruling. In a recent interview to The Wire-Hindi she said, “Jab Justice Khehar ne ye kahaki ye mamla legislature keliyehai to hamein laga ki is se hamari baat to bal milta hai ki desh mein Quran adharit Muslim family law hona chahiye.” [When Justice Khehar said that this matter is for the legislature, we felt that this supports our view that there should be a Quran-based Muslim family law in the country.] The demand per se is legitimate and long overdue, but it is also complicated by a political context wherein Muslim women and others may not be able to exercise reasonable control over the outcome of any such proposed law in Parliament, with the ruling party utilizing it to further its sectarian and divisive agenda. http://www.lawyerscollective.org/the-invisible-lawyer/need-gender-justice-minority-rights-not-either

3/3

Loading...

THE INVISIBLE LAWYER

11/21/2017 Need Both Gender-justice and Minority Rights, Not Either-Or! by Albeena Shakil - Lawyers Collective THE INVISIBLE LAWYER SPECIAL ISSUE TR...

202KB Sizes 0 Downloads 0 Views

Recommend Documents

The Invisible Aristocrat - PapuaWeb
53 See diagrams 1.1 and 1.2 for the extent of the Sriwijaya and Majapahit Enpires. 54 “Dua buah kerajaan Indonesia tel

The Invisible Church
Speaking of Death: America's New Sense of Mortality. Michael K. Bartalos, editor .... short-story writer Anton Chekhov,

The American Lawyer - Law.com
Featured Firms. Gary Martin Hays & Associates P.C.. 235 Peachtree St NE #400. Atlanta, GA 30303. 800-898-4297. Personal

The Invisible Man - CBSE Academic
May 3, 2012 - START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE INVISIBLE MAN ***. Produced by Andrew Sly. The Invisible Man. A

The Texas Divorce Lawyer: Dallas Divorce Lawyer and Family Attorney
FAMILY LAW ATTORNEYS IN DALLAS, TX. We Treat Your Case as If It Involved Our Own Families. Empathy is key to a good rela

Business Bankruptcy Lawyer Services | Lawyer To Lawyer Comerio
In cases like this, a Chapter 7 is the fastest, easiest, and most effective means of eliminating financial obligation. A

Invisible Man
The narrator of Invisible Man shows an interest in Ralph Waldo Emerson. ... as a novel addressing racial identity in mod

LECTURE "THE PROFESSION OF LAWYER"
Oct 23, 2010 - considerava serem os valores essenciais para o seu escritório. Disse que deveriam incluir: “Qualidade ina

The Invisible Thread Pdf Free | Minds
Mar 28, 2017 - guitar chord boxes pdf freehukum kekekalan energi mekanik pdf freethought reform and the psychology of to

the case of Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man
who took identity as their central theme, from slavery till the Civil Right movement era. Within the analysis of Ralph E

HD 6.5 90 Pihu (2018) | Madam Secretary HDTV 720p AC3 5.1 | N/A / N/A / N/A